| Pool 1 Standings | Pool 2 Standings |
| KFC | 2-4 | Cicchini Asphalt | 5-1 |
| Lee Mechanical | 4-2 | Firefighters | 1-5 |
| Madrigrano, Aiello, & Santarelli (MAS) | 3-3 | Limbach Chiropractic | 5-1 |
| Police Association | 3-3 | Pitts Brothers | 1-5 |
| Spot Drive-In | 1-5 | Super Sports | 5-1 |
Updated as of 5/15/2025
Pool 1: Police Association won the head-to-head competition tiebreaker beating MAS 7-3
1 seed: Lee Mechanical
2 seed: Police Association
Pool 2: Three-way tie between Cicchini Asphalt, Limbach Chiropractic, and Super Sports was determined by the run differential in head-to-head competition. Results below:
1 seed: Limbach Chiropractic (+13)
2 seed: Super Sports (0)
3 seed: Cicchini Asphalt (-13)